After meeting ex-RSS chief, Shia cleric approves ‘Vande Mataram’

Lucknow, Nov 9 (IANS) A leading Shia cleric has taken on India’s largest Islamic seminary and said that there was ‘nothing wrong’ if a Muslim sings the national anthem ‘Vande Mataram’.

‘I see nothing wrong for a Muslim to recite Vande Mataram as long as it means salutation to the nation and does not amount to offering prayers,’ Shia scholar and All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) member Maulana Hameedul Hasan told IANS.

The declaration came close on the heels of a similar announcement by another renowned Shia cleric and AIMPLB’s senior vice president, Maulana Kalbe Sadiq.

‘That is why I feel there was a need to explain the meaning of every word in the national song. I am sure that once it is clarified that there was no element of offering prayers in the song, all this controversy over it would come to rest,’ Hasan pointed out.

This follows the Maulana’s ‘heart-to-heart’ talk with former Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) chief K.C. Sudarshan, who in an unprecedented move drove down to the former’s residence here Sunday.

‘The aim of the meeting was to find ways to bridge the Hindu-Muslim divide that arose primarily on account of prevailing confusions about each other’s religious beliefs,’ Hasan said. ‘We have succeeded in breaking the ice and I am sure we will be able to resolve various issues that give rise to avoidable tensions between the two communities.’

On Nov 3, the Darul Uloom Deoband, India’s largest Islamic seminary, passed a resolution urging Muslims not to sing the ‘Vande Mataram’, saying the song went against Islamic principles. The resolution sparked a furore, both within and outside the Muslim community in India.

The Sunday meeting here was organised at the initiative of the Muslim Rashtriya Manch, a RSS brainchild.

It was rare occasion when a Maulana talked about misunderstandings among Hindus about the Koran and a RSS bigwig eulogised the life and achievements of Prophet Mohammad.

‘I told Janab Sudarshan sahib that the need of the hour was to remove all misunderstandings that many Hindus have about the Holy Koran, Islam as also about Indian Muslims who are unfortunately often labelled pro-Pakistanis,’ said Hasan.

‘These misgivings can only be brought to rest through an open dialogue between the two communities. I am sure the RSS can play a truly meaningful role towards achieving the goal.’

Seeking to dispel the common impression that Muslims were responsible for the creation of Pakistan, the Maulana said: ‘No Muslim has any soft corner for Pakistan. The bulk of Indian Muslims opposed the country’s partition.’

Interestingly, RSS stalwart Sudarshan also seemed to second the Maulana’s view by adding: ‘It were the British who brought about the partition in collusion with Jawaharlal Nehru.’

He termed the Hindu-Muslim divide a result of ‘vested political interests’ while hailing Prophet Mohammad as ‘preacher, social reformer, commander and statesman’.

Related Posts
RSS leader meets Muslim clerics to harmonise ties
Lucknow, Nov 9 (ANI): Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RRS) senior leader K S Sudarshan met Muslim clerics, including Shi'ite cleric Hamid-ul Hassan on Sunday. Sudarshan's meeting with the Muslim clerics was aimed at harmonizing ties between the two communities...
‘Vande mataram’ not un-Islamic, say two Muslim groups
Bhopal, Nov 5 (IANS) It is not un-Islamic to sing 'Vande mataram', two prominent Muslim groups in Madhya Pradesh said Thursday, two days after the clerics' body Jamiat Ulema-i-Hind approved an earlier fatwa against the national song. Claiming to have...
All marriages should be solemnized in local mosques, says Shia clerics
Lucknow, Oct 19 (ANI): The Shia Muslim Personal Law Board in Lucknow has made it mandatory for all Muslim marriages to be solemnized in local mosques irrespective of their financial status. The decision was taken at the meeting of the All India Shia...
Muslim clerics support fatwa on ‘Vande Mataram’
Deoband (Uttar Pradesh), Nov 3 (IANS) The Jamiat-e-Ulema-e-Hind, one of the largest organisations of Muslim clerics in India, Tuesday supported a decree against the national song 'Vande Mataram' on the ground that some of its lines were 'against the...
Muslim clergies dictum on Vande Mataram evokes protest
Lucknow, Nov 6 (ANI): Activists of Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) staged a mass protest here against the Muslims clergy for issuing fatwa, asking the Muslims not to sing India's national song Vande Mataram. The Jamiat Ulema-i-Hind passed the fatwa on Vande...
‘Ulemas won’t stop Muslims from singing Vande Mataram’
New Delhi, Nov 9 (IANS) In a bid to tone down the row over its fatwa against the singing of 'Vande Mataram', clerics from the Deoband Islamic seminary have said they won't stop Muslims from singing the national song but the fatwa would stay. The climbdown...

One Response to After meeting ex-RSS chief, Shia cleric approves ‘Vande Mataram’
  1. Madhukar N. Gogate
    November 15, 2009 | 11:26 am

    Regarding recent Deoband Fatwa against (Vande Mataram) song

    Deoband has exploited the freedom of speech given by Indian
    Constitution. The Constitution is fruit of India’s Freedom struggle,
    wherein many freedom fighters & martyrs sung Vande Mataram.

    Deoband & Pakistan too should honour Vande Mataram.
    Pakistan itself did not struggle for freedom from British Rulers.
    Pakistan was suddenly created by partitioning India.

    What does the song mean ? It says Salute to Motherland. It
    does not belittle Allah, in any way. In Muslim countries too,
    people salute to National Flag, to Head of Country.

    If Deoband is so touchy, why dont they issue a fatwa against
    (Jana Gana Mana) anthem ? It seeks blessings, with words
    Bhaarat Bhaagya Vidhaataa. (Vidhaataa) stands for Creator.
    All people in India, including Muslims, honour this anthem.
    It does not belittle Allah. Same applies to Vande Mataram.

    Better for all, if we come out of outdated religious doctrines.
    Quran is anti-Music. (Taliban banned Radio etc in Afghan).
    But that dictum has been overthrown by Muslims, leading to
    music stalwarts, Bismillah Khan, Bade Gulam Ali Khan etc.
    Hindus threw Manusmruti dictum putting women in bondage.

    — M. N. Gogate (Pune)
    (www.mngogate.com) (mngogate1932@yahoo.com)
    Website index page carries contact address, phone etc.
    Website article E15 > optional Roman script Indic languages

Leave a Reply


Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

Trackback URL http://news.armoks.com/after-meeting-ex-rss-chief-shia-cleric-approves-vande-mataram/21454/trackback/
who's online